The meeting focused on updates and discussions around nonlinear ads, particularly the progress and challenges with VAST, IAB standards, and server-side ad insertion in MPEG-DASH and HLS. Olivier shared insights from recent conversations with Google and the IAB, highlighting limitations in the current VAST and OpenRTB specifications for handling flexible ad layouts and the lack of mandatory signaling for ad types. The group discussed the need for more flexibility in ad formats beyond the current standardized options, especially for connected TV and potential future support for vertical video. Nicolas presented a framework for defining requirements and use cases for nonlinear ads in MPEG-DASH, emphasizing the roles of publishers, ad servers, presentation servers, and video players, and the importance of allowing publishers to control ad layout and duration. The conversation also covered device capabilities, graceful degradation, and the complexities of ensuring ads are rendered correctly and tracked appropriately, especially when different ad formats have different CPMs. The conversation ended with an agreement to further discuss and refine the requirements and use cases for nonlinear ads in the context of existing standards and emerging needs.
- David to follow up with Nicolas to capture different use cases and complexities for nonlinear ads in MPEG-DASH, ensuring alignment with VAST requirements.
- Nicolas to share the presentation slides and the link to the repo containing the requirements and use cases for nonlinear ads in MPEG-DASH with the group.
- All participants: Review Nicolas’ repo and provide feedback or ideas on the requirements and use cases for nonlinear ads in MPEG-DASH.
- Antitrust Statement and WG Discussion
Ad Interface Project Updates
- The team discussed updates on nonlinear ads and the common ad interface project led by Casey, which is expected to have more updates starting next week.
- David mentioned that the skippable ads work with Dave Glasson has stalled, and he plans to work on the 102 course soon.
- The group is also currently working on the ad creative signaling with HLS and DASH 2nd revision.
Ad Format Standardization Proposal
- Olivier presented Google’s proposal for standardized ad formats to the IAB Working Group, which defines safe areas on screen for ads. He noted that while Google’s approach focuses on squeeze back ads, David’s simulator work offers more flexibility with moving ads and overlays.
- The team agreed they should align with David’s approach and work with Google to implement the technology in VAST XML, though they acknowledged the IAB is unlikely to accept their current proposal due to the recent publication of the standardized spec.
IAB Ad Layout Specifications Discussion
- Olivier reported that while the IAB group discussed ad layout specifications, Google was the only company showing interest in the current proposal.
- The group discussed challenges with the current standardized format, including uncertainty about ad types and placement, with Olivier noting that publishers would need to figure out implementation details on their own.
- The discussion clarified that the current specifications are specifically designed for connected TVs with 16:9 aspect ratio, with potential future versions considering other formats like 9:16 vertical video.
CTV Ad Format Specifications
- The team discussed new ad format specifications for CTV, focusing on linear and nonlinear ads.
- Olivier explained that while future vertical and square formats are being considered, the current implementation targets CTV with 16×9 aspect ratio and L-shaped ads.
- Yasser suggested potential use cases for multi-view content with different camera angles, and Olivier indicated that specific use cases could be taken to the IAB for consideration.
- The team also discussed the release of VAST 4.4 specification, which includes new features for nonlinear ads, and Olivier shared links to the specifications in the chat.
Nonlinear Ads in MPEG-DASH
- Nicolas presented a project to describe requirements and use cases for nonlinear ads in MPEG-DASH before creating syntax, aiming to align with the DASH team on what to cover.
- The project involves four main actors: publisher (broadcaster or content creator), player, ad server, and ad format provider.
- Nicolas explained the goal is to extend existing MPEG-DASH syntax for linear ads to include nonlinear ads, overlays, and various ad formats like L-shaped and pause ads.
Video Player Ad Communication Model
- Nicolas explained the model where a video player communicates with an ad presentation server to handle ad placement, with the publisher owning the primary content and deciding on ad constraints.
- He detailed how the system works with both linear and non-linear ads, with the player enforcing publisher-imposed restrictions on ad duration and format.
- Nicolas clarified that the application serves as a communication tool rather than making decisions itself, and the build player composes the final on-screen experience by validating responses from the ad presentation server.
Publisher Ad Framework Responsibilities
- Nicolas led a discussion on defining publisher responsibilities in a framework for non-linear ad layouts, emphasizing that publishers should have control over ad types and formats displayed on their screens.
- The group discussed how video players, ad presentation servers, and ad decision servers would interact, with David highlighting the need to handle cases where players cannot support certain ad formats and Olivier suggesting API validation for ad layouts.
- Nicolas shared a repository containing detailed context and requirements documentation for the framework, which the team agreed to review further, with David committing to follow up on capturing different implementation scenarios.
Next Meeting: Wednesday, August 5, 2026 8am PDT