The meeting focused on updates and discussions around nonlinear ad signaling for DASH and HLS, with David presenting recent progress on working libraries and demos. The group discussed open issues related to capabilities signaling, such as the number of supported decoders, image overlay support, and potential audio and synchronization limitations. Rob and Olivier raised points about audio handling, image formats, and device-specific constraints. David demonstrated the nonlinear ad demos, showing different layouts and asset selection based on capabilities. The conversation also covered the need for explicit layout data in ad responses, even when using predefined IAB layouts, to ensure compatibility and tracking. Olivier provided an overview of upcoming topics for the Rennes meeting, including nonlinear ad formats, ad signaling in DASH and HLS, client-guided ad measurement with CMCD v2, and contextual ads. Marc, a new participant from Apple, was introduced to the ongoing work. The conversation ended with a brief mention of other projects and the sharing of presentation materials.
- David to check in with Casey for updates on the common ad interface progress.
- David to start working on MOQ and ad signaling with the OpenMOQ Alliance in a couple of weeks, and gather input from the group.
- David to update the SVTA spec with the latest nonlinear ad work for HLS and DASH, aiming to complete it for Rennes and HLS Interest Day.
- David to show the nonlinear ad demos and work to Google to align on similar VAST-based approaches.
- Post the link to the presentation deck and shared drive, and provide access to Marc upon request.
- Marc to catch up on the existing presentations and materials shared.
- Olivier to look into the agenda and timing for the Rennes meeting next week.
- Olivier to coordinate with the IAB to get CMCD V2 accepted as a standard for server-side ad tracking.
- Olivier to explore with the IAB the possibility of server-side Open Measurement (OMSDK) for viewability.
- Olivier to coordinate with Sarge on contextual ads work for Rennes.
- Antitrust Statement and WG Discussion
Ad Signaling Progress
- David discussed ongoing work on ad query signaling and the common ad interface, mentioning he needs to check in with Casey for updates.
- He announced plans to start working on MOQ and ad signaling with the OpenMOQ Alliance in the coming weeks.
- David reported significant progress on creative signaling for DASH and HLS, including the development of working libraries and demos that will be presented at Rennes and the HLS Interest Day, where they have a speaking spot.
- The team identified capabilities around decoder support as a key open item that needs to be addressed through both server-side and player-side logic.
Player Capabilities Determination Approaches
- David discussed the need to determine player capabilities, specifically focusing on how many video decoders a device can support and whether image overlays are allowed.
- He proposed two approaches: using a simple enumeration system with a single value or implementing a more explicit route that specifies individual capabilities like video decoders and image support.
- David noted that the demo currently uses the more explicit approach but requested feedback from the team on which method would be better.
Multiple Media Element Support Discussion
- Rob and David discussed technical considerations for supporting multiple media elements, including decoders, compositing, and playback functionality.
- They acknowledged potential conflicts with certain types of functionality, such as simultaneous audio playback versus trick play, and agreed that more explicit configurations might be needed in some cases.
- David noted that synchronization capabilities could be added in a future version (potentially V2), but decided to avoid implementing it in the current version due to complexity and varying needs across use cases.
Video Ad Audio Handling Discussion
- The team discussed audio handling capabilities for video ads, particularly around controlling audio priority and muting options.
- Olivier explained that IAB already defines options for specifying whether ads have audio or are muted, with the ability to unmute ads while muting the main content.
- The discussion touched on whether the RSDK should handle audio toggling between ads and main content, though this was identified as a complex capability issue.
- Marc, who was attending his first meeting as someone from Apple’s live streaming team, joined the conversation and asked about specifying particular image formats or types, though this topic was not further developed in the transcript.
MIME Types and Device Formats
- The team discussed challenges with MIME types and device capabilities for handling different media formats, particularly images and videos.
- David explained that they are working on defining supported formats at a more granular level and implementing option sets that allow for multiple format alternatives when default options aren’t supported by a device.
- The discussion highlighted the need to accommodate devices with limitations on specific formats, including animated graphics and different video formats like JPEG, HDR images, and HEIF.
Advanced Ad Format Capabilities
- Rob explained that the new capabilities being discussed would work in addition to existing HLS and DASH systems, which already provide codec selection features.
- David demonstrated a demo showing how the new system can handle concurrent interstitial classes with different ad formats, including both linear and non-linear ad experiences.
- The system can now support video ads with multiple decoders instead of just static image ads, allowing for more complex layouts and formats like L-shaped ads that require multiple videos.
SVTA Spec and Library Updates
- David demonstrated the squeeze back feature and discussed plans to update the SVTA spec with work done on HLS and DASH.js libraries.
- The team aims to have the updated spec and working libraries ready for Rennes and the HLS Interest Day next week, with native Swift libraries as the next priority.
- David raised an open question about whether to include optional anchor positioning for viewports in the specification, seeking input from Marc and Rob on whether to support this feature in V1.
Visual Overlay System Implementation Discussion
- The team discussed implementing a visual overlay system, with David sharing examples of how to define windows for lower-third displays and demonstrating video capabilities.
- Olivier suggested checking with Google about their similar implementation in VAST, and David mentioned plans to meet with Google representatives to align on their approach.
- The discussion focused on technical implementation details and potential collaboration with Google’s similar project.
Nonlinear Ad Format Specifications
- The team discussed nonlinear ad formats and layout specifications, with David explaining that while IAB defines standard layouts like upper left overlays, the system should still require explicit layout data to be provided rather than relying on default assumptions.
Q4 Member Meeting Session Agenda
- Olivier outlined upcoming agenda items for next week’s meeting, including nonlinear format work, ad signaling in DASH HLS v3, client-guided ad measurement with CMCD v2, and contextual ads work.
- The discussion also covered how even composited streams would need layout data for click tracking and other interactive elements, with Paramount’s Casey mentioned as working on similar challenges with composite streams.
Next Meeting: Q4 2026 Member Meeting in Rennes, France – October 7-8, 2026 – See Online Agenda for WG Session Times
Link to Presentation Deck: https://aro.streamingvideoalliance.org/get/8970
Link to Advertising WG Google Drive:
https://drive.google.com/drive/u/0/folders/0AOWV_IyXCf29Uk9PVA
(For access requests, reach out to Hali, hmorek@amsl.com)