SVTA_LOGO_FINAL_revised_2022

DASH-IF IOP Content Protection and Security Meeting Minutes
March 18th, 2026 9:00am to 10:00am PT</p

Attendees

Laurent Piron (Nagra Kudelski)
Erik Pena (DoveRunner)
Vladimir Zivkovic (Irdeto)
Nicolas Weil (Amazon)
Yasser Syed (Streaming Video Technology Alliance (SME))

Minutes

 

  • Summary

The meeting focused on reviewing watermarking specifications, with Vladimir presenting updates to segment naming requirements for media time-based variant selection across different streaming formats. The discussion covered how segment names should incorporate media timestamps rather than sequence numbers, with particular attention to DASH, HLS “old-style”, and HLS “new-style” (CMAF-aligned) implementations. The team addressed technical challenges around variable segment durations and how CDN edge functions would need different calculation rules for different naming schemes. Vladimir also presented updates on CMAF and non-CMAF ingest processes, including detailed diagrams showing how media time information is conveyed through different protocols like EBP. The group agreed to keep explicit descriptions in the text while acknowledging that further optimization and mandatory requirements would need to be defined in future discussions.

  • Action Items
  • Vladimir: Expand and clarify in the document the formulas and methods for how the CDN can derive the bit position value in each segment naming case (DASH time, DASH number, HLS old style, HLS CMAF-aligned), to remove ambiguity for implementers, for next meeting.
  • All participants: Review the updated document sections (especially segment naming and ingest details) and provide feedback or suggestions for optimization/removal of ASCII art or references as needed.
  • Lindsey: Review the watermarking API document sent by Laurent and confirm if it is acceptable to go through the SVTA process.
  • All participants: Prepare for next call on the document in 2 weeks.
  • Antitrust Statement & Watermarking System Design Overview
  • The team discussed watermarking implementation, with Vladimir presenting an updated document that included a system diagram explaining how timestamps and sequence IDs are handled in the encoding process.
  • Vladimir demonstrated how the encoder calculates sequence IDs from timestamps and how the watermarking preprocessor converts these IDs into bits for watermarking.
  • The discussion included details about how segment names are generated from epoch timestamps and how CDN calculate bit positions from segment names.

Media Time-Based Variant Requirements

  • Vladimir presented requirements for media time-based variant selection, focusing on segment naming conventions for DASH and CMAF A/B watermarking cases.
  • Laurent asked if the specific format presented was mandatory, to which Vladimir clarified it was an example and confirmed that time elements are required for the system to function.
  • The discussion focused on identifying which specific elements within the format are mandatory requirements.

Video Segment Time Anchoring Discussion

  • Vladimir and Nicolas discussed the concept of time anchoring in video segmentation, particularly focusing on how segment names are structured.
  • They explored how different streaming technologies handle media sequence numbers (MSN), with Vladimir explaining that while older HLS specifications required MSN to increment by 1, newer versions (particularly CMAF-aligned HLS) align more closely with DASH specifications.
  • The discussion touched on how CDN handling of segment names works, though the full technical details about CDN implementation were left for future discussion.

Segment Naming Schemes Implementation Discussion

  • Vladimir and Nicolas discussed the implementation of different segment naming schemes in DASH and HLS, particularly focusing on $time and $number approaches.
  • They explored the challenges of maintaining compatibility with CDN edge functions, which currently rely on file extensions to determine calculation rules.
  • The discussion concluded with an agreement that while mixing different schemes within a single CDN distribution should be avoided, the responsibility for proper configuration would lie with implementers at the origin level, rather than being enforced through specifications.

$Numbers Implementation in DASH

  • Vladimir and Nicolas discussed the implementation of $numbers in DASH, focusing on ensuring sequentiality and handling variable segment durations.
  • Vladimir explained that $number should be sequential and based on a fixed grid system derived from the leading timestamp of the first frame, rather than using absolute timestamps.
  • Nicolas raised concerns about how the CDN would understand the baseline value for $numbers and handle varying segment durations due to breaks or encoder re-syncs.
  • Vladimir acknowledged the challenge of variable segment durations but suggested that sporadic events could be managed by returning to a consistent grid pattern after disruptions.

Video Watermarking Techniques Discussion

  • The team discussed watermarking techniques for variable-length video segments.
  • Vladimir presented updates on segment naming approaches, including CMAF and non-CMAF ingest methods.
  • Yasser asked about ad insertion handling, and Vladimir explained that ads not watermarked through the main process would still work through the fixed segment duration definition.
  • The team agreed to keep detailed descriptions of CMAF and non-CMAF ingest methods in the document.

 

Next Meeting: Tuesday, March 24, 2026 7am PDT

Have A Question ABout Membership?

Schedule A Meeting

[hfcm id="18"]

Send An Email

Don’t want to schedule a face-to-face meeting just now? No problem. Simply send your membership question to info@streamingvideoalliance.org or fill out the form below and someone will get back to you as soon as possible.