The meeting focused on reviewing and finalizing the watermarking specification document, with Laurent presenting updated changes that consolidated mathematical formulas and definitions into a single section to avoid repetition throughout the document. The group discussed concerns about epoch time flexibility, with Nicolas raising questions about alternative time bases and whether implementers should have options to override the default 1970 epoch. The team also discussed recent FairPlay developments, including new key types (advisory keys and video session keys) introduced in SDK version 27. The group also discussed the proposal to MPEG for early announcement of key rotation signaling in DASH manifests that would need coordination with MPEG processes. The group debated the best approach for handling key rotation proposals, considering whether to work through MPEG meetings or maintain control within their working group, with suggestions made to establish an ad hoc group to collaborate with MPEG processes while maintaining industry alignment.
Laurent
- Update the watermarking document to include a note/footnote stating that using an epoch time other than January 1st, 1970 is possible but carries risk for the end-to-end solution and must be communicated to all involved systems, then share the updated watermarking document with the group for final review and then manage the publication process.
- Coordinate with Jason to invite Apple to a security meeting to present and explain the new FairPlay SDK 27 features, including the video session key.
- Check and update the meeting schedule, potentially skipping the next call and moving to a bi-weekly cadence on Tuesdays.
Valentijn
- Reach out to Alex G. regarding the MPEG proposal on early announcement of key rotation signaling in DASH and suggest that the MPEG ad hoc group works in collaboration with the CPS group and also follow up with Mohammed to see if he can provide more information from the MPEG meeting.
- Antitrust Statement & WG Discussion
Watermarking Specification Review
- The team reviewed and finalized the watermarking specification document, with Laurent making cleanup changes to consolidate formulas and definitions in one section.
- The group discussed the use of epoch time and agreed to add a note stating that changing the default epoch from January 1, 1970 to any other date requires all systems to be aware of the change.
SDK Version 27 Features following HLS Interest Day
- Laurent discussed new features in SDK version 27, including a video session key for protecting keys, which was not announced publicly. The team discussed the need to understand the impact of these changes and agreed to potentially raise the topic at the next SVTA meeting in California.
- Valentijn suggested inviting Apple to present and explain the new features to ensure proper implementation across all parties.
- The team discussed Apple’s new FairPlay SDK 27 features, particularly the introduction of advisory keys and multi-key responses.
- Laurent explained that these new features require the latest iOS and tvOS versions, though the team noted that Apple device updates happen quickly and fragmentation may not be a significant issue.
- The team discussed challenges with video session keys and what it could mean for DASH compared to HLS if any impact exists.
MPEG Proposal Process Discussion
- Thasso and others raised concerns about the approach of bringing DASH updates to MPEG, questioning how this would affect their current work and timeline, with Laurent noting that MPEG changes typically take 18 months to implement.
- The group discussed the process for submitting proposals to MPEG, particularly regarding early announcement of key rotation signaling.
- They agreed that Nicolas’s suggestion to create an ad hoc group working in collaboration with Alex’s proposal would be more effective than sending a liaison, as the liaison process would be too time-consuming given the upcoming MPEG meeting.
- Valentijn committed to suggesting this approach and sharing the results in Slack.
- The group also briefly discussed C2PA initiatives, noting that progress was being made through Thomas presenting proposals to C2PA.
Next Meeting: Wednesday, October 28, 2026 9 am PDT