The meeting focused on coordinating the next face-to-face session scheduled for the following week in Berlin, where the team plans to have a dedicated watermarking session in the afternoon to make progress on the document. Vladimir presented changes he made to the document, including text improvements, cleaning the sidecar-based developments section, and fixing around fixed segment duration and sequence number calculations. The team discussed technical details about watermarking implementation, including encoder integration requirements and CDN functionality, with Laurent confirming that content steering should not be an issue as long as the CDN logic is implemented consistently across all CDNs. Yasser raised concerns about document references and ensuring the correct version of the UHDF watermarking API document is accessible, with Laurent explaining that a new updated version is in the final approval process at SVTA and will be published in mid-June.
Laurent
- Review and verify the text and figures added/modified by Vladimir in the document, especially around fixed segment duration, watermarking integration, and related references, and prepare feedback for the face-to-face meeting.
- Copy-paste and restore clean versions of broken pictures/figures in the document from local files.
- Check with Mehmet regarding the note and figure related to fixed segment pace and add/modify text as appropriate, possibly removing or clarifying the picture and note as discussed.
- Update document references from UHDF reference 8 to the new version (reference 13) once the new version is published and available, and ensure old references are removed or updated to avoid confusion.
- Share the thread regarding the update of the watermarking API document with Yasser for reference and coordination on document management.
Vladimir
- Propose additional text for the CDN section to better align with media timestamp synchronization and watermarking logic, and address optional "+1" handling, for review at the face-to-face meeting.
Collaboration
- Yasser and Laurent: Ensure the SVTA/UHDF website and document repository are updated to reflect the new version of the watermarking API document, and remove or clearly deprecate older versions to avoid confusion.
- Antitrust Statement & Watermarking Meeting Planning Discussion
- Laurent and Vladimir discussed plans for an upcoming face-to-face meeting next week where they will have a session on watermarking topics. The session will be in the afternoon of Thursday, with the goal of spending 1-2 hours on watermarking discussions.
Document Updates and Watermarking Integration
- Vladimir discussed updates to a document, focusing on integrating watermarking into the encoder and addressing references to the UHDF API specification.
- Vladimir added that the sequence number and an optional plus-one are crucial for backward compatibility, and he requested review of these additions.
- Vladimir discussed changes he made to the watermarking section, removing vendor-specific statements and restructuring the content to be more neutral while maintaining references to previous definitions.
- Vladimir discussed removing a picture and node from a document, suggesting more explicit text around CDN functionality, particularly regarding file naming and timestamp handling.
- Laurent agreed to check on removing the content and proposed that Vladimir could provide additional text.
- Yasser raised a question about content steering, specifically regarding redirects between CDNs, and Vladimir explained that while shared origins would remain transparent, different packagers might require translation of naming conventions.
- They agreed that content steering is not an issue as long as the CDN logic is consistent across all CDNs.
- Vladimir made updates to a formula for consistency.
- The conversation also touched on a previous discussion about sidecar implementation and the assumption that segments contain either audio or video but not both within the same file.
- Yasser mentioned a reference to a UHD Forum document, confirming its location on the SVTA website. Laurent explained that the watermarking API was originally developed in the UHD Forum and has been updated to a new version (13) that is currently in the final approval process at the board of SVTA, with an expected update in mid-June.
- Yasser and Laurent discussed the need to update references to the new version and ensure there are no duplicate or outdated documents.
- The team agreed to review the updates during the upcoming face-to-face meeting in Berlin next week.
Next Meeting: Wednesday, June 24, 2026 9 am PDT