The meeting focused on reviewing MPEG-DASH specifications and related technical discussions. Thomas led the meeting, covering key topics including MPEG meeting updates where they discussed bugs in the 6th edition and key rotation signaling for CMAF. The group extensively discussed key rotation alignment between DASH and CMAF specifications, with Iraj proposing that DASH-IF and DVB experts collaborate to ensure consistency before the next MPEG meeting. Mohammed presented work on exploring feature definitions, noting that two approaches were complementary and could be combined to create a new annex for easier external SDO references. Torbjörn raised a technical issue about EMST boxes for C2PA video segment signing, particularly regarding checksum placement in chunked segments. The meeting also covered C2PA collaboration efforts, where Thomas reported on presenting DASH-IF's technical support and expertise to the C2PA working group. Additional topics included updates on reference tools, with Torbjörn sharing a new Go-based validator for DASH that can run in web assembly, and Laurent presenting an updated watermarking specification that includes time-based A/B watermarking options.
Â
Thomas
- Share the MPEG meeting output documents and the feature-related documents with the group for review.
- Initiate a two-week community group review for the watermarking specification update.
- Coordinate with Stephan and Alan to finalize the publication process for the LCVC community review.
- Follow up with the DVB project office to initiate a formal liaison agreement between DVB and C2PA.
- Schedule a dedicated call in the December timeframe to discuss the feature definition approach with MPEG and DVB.
- Schedule a separate call in the December timeframe to identify how MPEG can support ITF efforts and determine potential shared work.
Torbjörn
- Share the link to the Go-based DASH validator in the meeting notes.
- Continue exploring the EMSG box issue for C2PA chunked segments and consider using V1 event messages for negative time offsets.
Collaboration
- Content Protection Task Force / DVB: Review the key rotation signaling solutions and provide feedback to the MPEG DASH ad hoc before the next MPEG meeting.
- DVB: Provide feedback and suggestions on merging the two proposed approaches for the feature definition annex.
Â
- Antitrust Statement & WG Discussion
Liaison Partners and C2PA Updates
- Thomas led the meeting where he planned to review an agenda covering liaison partners, MPEG updates, and C2PA discussions.
- Thomas mentioned that Daniel was absent and noted that Thasso was also not present.
- The meeting began with Thomas asking if anyone had specific questions, including Laurent’s question about watermarking for the ETSI spec which was mentioned.
EMST and MPEG Updates Meeting
- The meeting covered updates on EMST boxes for C2 and the completion of the community review for Part 7, which closed on October 31.
- Thomas confirmed they were ready to move forward with the next steps.
- The group discussed recent MPEG meetings, where small bugs in the 6th edition were identified and addressed, and new features including an energy attribute were considered.
- No new updates were reported from the DVB side, and the conversation ended with a brief mention of ongoing discussions about push-based DASH and RFC updates related to HP 2.
CMAF and DASH Key Rotation
- The group discussed key rotation signaling for CMAF and DASH, with Alex explaining that MPEG adopted an HLS-like signaling approach in amendment one of the seventh edition.
- Iraj proposed aligning the CMAF and DASH solutions before the next MPAC meeting, while Mohammed suggested moving beyond the previous CPS discussions to streamline the process.
- Thomas proposed including stakeholders like the Content Protection Security Task Force and DVB experts in a December meeting to discuss and finalize the solution, with Alex suggesting an ad hoc meeting to discuss details before presenting to a larger group.
Liaison Agreement and Document Review
- Thomas discussed the need for documents to be shared with members under the liaison agreement, with plans to review them in the December extended meeting.
- He mentioned a discussion about energy attribution in Amendment 1 and an invitation for the IETF to participate in a group call in the December timeframe.
- Thomas also highlighted a document edited by Mohammad on exploring the definition of features, noting that the inputs were found to be predominantly complementary, with plans for a dedicated call on this topic in December.
DASH Tool Feature Grouping Approaches
- Mohammed presented two complementary approaches for grouping DASH tools into features to make it easier for external SDOs to reference MPEG-DASH features consistently.
- The team decided to map these approaches against a specific feature, low latency DASH, to test their effectiveness in a concrete instantiation.
- Thomas announced that the document would be shared for review, and the group agreed to work with reference tools, Test.js, and LiveSim to progress this initiative.
C2PA Video Segment Signing Challenge
- Torbjörn presented a technical challenge with implementing C2PA video segment signing in Lysine 2, specifically regarding the placement of checksums in chunked segments.
- The discussion revealed that current DASH specifications require EMSD boxes at the start of segments, but this conflicts with the need to place checksums at the end of chunked segments for latency reasons.
- The group determined that while a solution exists using EMSD version 1 with absolute timestamps, they should avoid using version 0 due to CMAF compatibility issues, though no immediate solution was identified for the current implementation challenge.
DASH-IF Working Group Updates
- Thomas reported on the DASH-IF working group activities, including progress on C2PA collaboration and the creation of a new Go-based validator for DASH by Torbjorn.
- The team discussed updates on various technical topics including reference tools, deployment features, and watermarking specifications, with Laurent presenting an updated watermarking specification that needs community review.
- Upcoming meetings were scheduled including CMCD discussions on November 17 and a regular meeting on November 24, with plans for an extended meeting in early December involving MPEG and DVB discussions.
Next Meeting: Tuesday, November 10, 2026 9 am PST
Chat Record:
- Thomas Stockhammer (Nov 3, 2026, 9:25 AM)
https://docs.google.com/document/d/10a15zxaFUdGNYqljrb8tM_BfMTXoIFv52QVmO_ynjeM/edit?usp=sharing