Encoding and Packaging Meeting Minutes
2026-10-21 09:00:00 to 10:00:00 PT

Attendees

Yuriy Reznik (Disney Streaming Service)
Dmitriy Shmakov (Elecard)
Yasser Syed (Streaming Video Technology Alliance (SME))

Minutes

  • Summary

The meeting focused on reviewing the Contribution Protocols document, which has been completed and is now under member review. Yuriy presented updates including added co-editor Dzmitriy and minor language improvements, noting that the document covers various protocols and deployment recommendations while intentionally deferring some topics like WebRTC to future revisions. The group discussed potential future work, including developing best practices for configuration parameters and performance metrics for transcoders, with plans to create educational documents harmonizing different vendor terminology and potentially conducting anonymized encoder comparisons similar to CableLabs' approach. Dzmitriy offered to present their existing testing framework for rate distortion curves at the next meeting, and the group explored using both CPU and GPU testing approaches while focusing on modern codecs like AVC, AV1, and HEVC.

 

 

  • Action Items
  • Dzmitriy to prepare a short presentation for the next meeting showing the testing framework/product used to generate rate-distortion curves.
  • Yuriy to fix the coloring in the deployment recommendations heatmap (specifically the OTT section) to be consistent with other ratings.
  • Yuriy to generate a draft or outline for the next meeting regarding the proposed encoder performance metrics and evaluation framework.
  • Yuriy to reach out to encoder vendors (including Harmonica/Mediacan and others) to gauge interest in a codec comparison study.
  • Yuriy to ask Alex to contribute input on important encoding metrics from a Netflix perspective.

 

  • Antitrust Statement and WG Discussion

Contribution Protocols Document Review

  • Yuriy led a meeting with four participants to review the Contribution Protocols document, which is now complete in scope and content and has been updated with editorial changes and grammar corrections.
  • Link to the document –
  • He added Dzmitriy as a co-editor and noted that the document is currently under members' review with version 1.0 status.
  • The discussion included a caveat about Meta's announcement of their own contribution protocol based on MRQ, though Yuriy emphasized that this is still new technology with limited information available.

MRQS Protocol Standardization Discussion

  • Yuriy explained that different entities are creating their own versions of protocols for internal use only, using an early implementation of the MRQS spec that was developed before the standardization process began.
  • He noted that while these implementations are currently deployable for private use, the specification is not yet finalized and standardization is still ongoing.
  • Yuriy suggested that when the specification matures and broader community interest develops, SVTA should step up to promote standardized implementation across all entities.

Protocol Taxonomy and Deployment Guidelines

  • Yuriy presented a taxonomy document that categorizes different protocols based on their properties and deployment recommendations, including heatmaps showing optimal and non-optimal deployment scenarios.
  • He noted that the document is still open for review and suggested it should be finalized within a quarter, with publication planned for the end of the year.
  • Yuriy mentioned potential future work on best practices for configuration parameters and performance metrics of transcoders, suggesting the creation of a harmonized document mapping different vendor terms to standard definitions.

Video Encoding Performance Documentation Plans

  • Yuriy discussed plans for video encoding performance documentation, focusing on codecs including AVC, AV1, and HEVC, with potential consideration of AV2.
  • The team explored creating performance measurement guidelines and potentially developing a more credible codec comparison report similar to CableLabs' approach, which would anonymize encoder vendors to maintain confidentiality.
  • Yuriy proposed this could help demonstrate the value of premium encoders compared to open-source implementations like FFmpeg, potentially regaining industry interest in such comparisons.

Testing Framework Discussion Meeting

  • Yuriy and Dzmitriy discussed a testing framework for rate distortion curves that Dzmitriy's company developed, which is similar to MSU's work but more comprehensive.
  • They agreed that Dzmitriy would present their product at the next meeting as a potential first contribution to the project.
  • Yuriy emphasized the need to start conversations with encoder vendors and address misconceptions about FFmpeg's capabilities in the transcoding industry.

Video Codec Testing Methodologies

  • Yuriy and Yasser discussed the challenges in testing and comparing different video codec implementations, highlighting the need for more scientific and standardized approaches to evaluate encoding tools and metrics.
  • They identified issues with current ad hoc testing methods and emphasized the importance of accounting for preprocessing filters, in-loop filters, and film grain handling in encoder comparisons.
  • Dzmitriy inquired about the potential use of StreamYard Studio for their investigation, and Yuriy suggested it could be useful for extracting statistics and estimating metrics like PSNR and VMAF.
  • Dzmitriy proposed creating educational documents on video encoding parameters and encoder performance metrics, with Yuriy suggesting the inclusion of PSNR distribution analysis for better evaluation.

Encoder Performance Metrics Framework Proposal

  • Yuriy proposed creating an Encoding Parameters and Encoder Performance Metrics document that would include statistics on QP values and establish a comprehensive evaluation framework.
  • The team discussed incorporating metrics for advertising content integration and potentially working with encoder vendors to demonstrate performance differences through scientific documentation and testing.
  • They agreed to gather input from various vendors including Alex from Netflix regarding VMAF metrics, and discussed using both SVTA content and sports content from the Deutsches Football League for testing purposes.

 

 

 

Next Meeting:  Wednesday, November 4, 2026 9am PST

 

 

 

Have A Question ABout Membership?

Schedule A Meeting

Send An Email

Don’t want to schedule a face-to-face meeting just now? No problem. Simply send your membership question to info@streamingvideoalliance.org or fill out the form below and someone will get back to you as soon as possible.

"*" indicates required fields

Name*
Email*