The group discussed the challenges and complexities surrounding low latency streaming, particularly in the context of live sports and advertising. They explored the contrasting needs of different stakeholders, such as ITV’s requirement for high latency for ad insertion versus the NFL’s emphasis on low latency for sports bars. The conversation highlighted the tension between technical capabilities and business priorities, with Robin noting that buffers are often necessary for maintaining video quality despite adding latency. The group also considered the role of artificial intelligence in potentially reducing latency through predictive encoding and discussed the potential for using C2PA metadata to standardize latency measurements across the streaming chain.
- Rob: Write up a summary (2-3 sentences) in the appropriate syntax to propose measuring latency at each stage (encoder, packager, etc.) as a potential work item for the group
- Robin: Contact Adam Goldberg (and possibly Michael) at C2PA/CTA to discuss the possibility of using C2PA metadata for latency measurement/timestamps throughout the delivery chain
- Antitrust Statement & Sports Broadcasting Next Steps
- The main purpose of the meeting was to discuss next steps regarding live versus low latency sports broadcasting, though no specific agenda was set.
- Robin noted that he hadn’t seen any updates on Slack from co-chairs regarding the discussion topic, and the group was waiting for additional participants including Florence and Michael to join.
Streaming Latency Industry Insights
- Robin discussed insights from a recent meeting about latency in streaming, highlighting contrasting views from industry representatives.
- An ITV representative argued that lower latency was unnecessary for ad insertion, while an NFL representative emphasized its importance for sports streaming, particularly in bars.
- Robin also mentioned BBC’s efforts to reduce iPlayer latency to match broadcast standards.
- The group explored the concept of “decorations” in HTTP requests and responses, with Rob explaining its role in adding metadata. Rob also shared information about a 3.5-second delay caused by an encoder device inserting Scuddy messages, which adds an additional 7 seconds of uncontrolled delay to the process.
Video Ad Insertion Challenges Discussion
- Robin and Chris discussed challenges in video ad insertion, particularly around frame accuracy and synchronization.
- Robin highlighted that traditional broadcast systems have been frame-accurate since the 1950s, and this precision is important for ITV’s transition to streaming.
- Chris shared insights from a meeting with Yo Space and IAB Tech Lab materials, suggesting that lower latency requirements for ad insertion might be acceptable, especially for non-intrusive ad formats like squeeze ads or in-screen ads.
FAST Channel Advertising Strategies
- The discussion focused on advertising in FAST channels, with Robin explaining how ITV produces content with ad pods in mind, including reminders and recaps between segments.
- Chris and Robin discussed how latency might not be a priority for FAST channels, as piracy concerns are minimal due to the business benefits of increased viewership.
- Robin noted that many FAST channels lack DRM protection, and Rob shared an example from Sony where some channels had zero viewers but were still published due to business incentives.
Low-Latency Streaming Implementation Challenges
- Rob and Robin discussed the challenges of implementing low-latency streaming, particularly in live sports broadcasting.
- They identified that while low latency is important, the current advertising and content delivery models present significant barriers.
- The discussion centered on whether there is sufficient demand and willingness to pay for low-latency streaming services, with Rob questioning if the sports leagues and networks would invest in such technology given their typical development cycles.
- They concluded by considering whether to document their findings in a paper, exploring the question of whether low latency is necessary or valuable enough to drive market adoption.
Evolution of Streaming Technology
- Robin discussed the evolution of streaming technology, explaining how CDNs initially handled video as chunks similar to websites, which led to chunk-based encoders becoming prevalent.
- He described the current phase of breaking chunks into smaller bits for faster delivery, noting that WebRTC offers low latency but doesn’t scale well without custom CDN infrastructure, which requires significant investment like Amazon’s custom network.
- Robin concluded by highlighting that while technology is evolving toward smaller fragments, buffering and network quality remain fundamental challenges that need to be addressed.
Streaming Buffer Mechanisms Discussion
- Robin and Chris discussed the role of buffers in streaming media playback, with Robin explaining that while delivery networks can improve efficiency, players will likely continue using buffers of 5-10 seconds for reliability.
- Chris suggested the possibility of buffer-aware players that adapt more closely to real-time streaming, and Robin confirmed that some smart players already implement such mechanisms, though they may be proprietary or have limited open-source equivalents.
- Robin mentioned that larger streaming companies are testing very low latency solutions, aiming for no more than 3% of users experiencing noticeable delays.
Latency and Video Delivery Challenges
- Chris and Robin discussed the role of facilitators or agents in addressing latency issues, referencing Ali’s previous research on ABR algorithms. T
- hey explored the trade-offs between latency and quality, particularly with different video codecs like HEVC and AV1.
- Robin explained the challenges of look-ahead processing in live streaming and suggested that AI could potentially help reduce latency in ad decisioning.
- Chris shared his work with IMAX, including their transition from monitoring software to focusing on delivering live events to theaters and homes.
- The conversation concluded with a mention of standardizing automated latency measurement throughout the video delivery chain.
Video Latency Measurement Challenges
- The team discussed challenges in measuring video latency across the entire delivery chain, from camera to player.
- They explored potential solutions including revising existing measurement parameters and leveraging C2PA (Content Authenticity Platform) metadata for timestamping content.
- Robin agreed to consult with Adam Goldberg from Sony/CTA about using C2PA for latency measurement, while Rob was tasked with drafting a standards-based question about continuing deterministic measurement processes through the delivery chain.
- The discussion concluded without reaching final conclusions, but identified two potential work items for further exploration.
Next Meeting: Thursday, April 2, 2026 9am PDT