The meeting focused on discussing latency measurement challenges in streaming video, with participants exploring several key topics. Robin shared insights from recent industry meetings, including contradictory perspectives on latency reduction from different content providers like ITV and NFL, highlighting how different business models affect latency requirements. The group discussed Content Provenance 2A (CP2A), a digital authentication system that could potentially be used for measuring and verifying latency data, with participants noting that companies like EZDRM and Qualabs are already working on implementing this technology. The conversation also covered player reporting metrics, with participants debating whether players intentionally request older content segments to avoid buffering issues, potentially adding 20-30 seconds of unnecessary latency. The conversation ended with discussion of upcoming NAB events and plans to potentially invite CP2A experts to future meetings to explore collaboration opportunities.
- Robin: Reach out to EZDRM and Qualabs regarding their work on C2PA and live streaming/low latency, and consider inviting them to a future meeting to share information
- Robin: Follow up with Glenn Dean regarding the new work item on latency and networking, providing updated feedback on the reality and progress of related standards efforts
- Robin: Monitor C2PA developments at NAB, especially live profile and related implementations
- Robin: Ping Florence to check on her status and availability
- All: Discuss and coordinate NAB plans and meetings via Slack
- Robin: Visit Michael’s booth at NAB to see the latency measurement demo
- Robin: Continue investigating and proposing standardized player reporting metrics (e.g., via CMCD) to improve latency transparency
- Robin: Add C2PA/latency measurement and related standards work to the agenda for the next meeting for more formal discussion and planning of next steps
- Antitrust Statement & Broadcast Latency and CP2A Initiative
- The group discussed upcoming industry events and latency measurement challenges in broadcasting.
- Robin shared insights from a recent meeting in Burbank where different organizations had conflicting views on latency reduction based on their specific business needs, particularly around advertising insertion.
- The discussion then focused on Content Provenance 2A (CP2A), a new industry initiative that uses cryptographic authentication to verify content throughout the distribution chain.
- Rob mentioned that EZDRM has already developed a video service using CP2A technology, and the group identified potential opportunities to explore CP2A’s application to latency measurement, though many technical questions remain unanswered about implementation and standardization.
Live Streaming and Player Metrics
- The team discussed reaching out to EZDRM and Qualabs regarding live streaming investments and confirmed that their next call would not conflict with NAB, which Michael noted he would attend.
- Robin expressed concerns about player reporting metrics, suggesting they may be outdated and proposed developing a more standardized approach that would hold players more accountable for their performance.
- The discussion touched on how players might intentionally request safely latent segments to improve performance metrics, though this was presented as a hypothesis rather than a confirmed issue.
Video Streaming Buffer Performance Discussion
- The discussion focused on buffering and latency issues in video streaming, particularly regarding player behavior and CDN performance.
- Michael explained that players intentionally request content from 20 seconds in the past to ensure buffer stability, which is not a fault but a designed approach to handle network variability.
- Robin proposed implementing a reporting metric to measure the actual buffer length in seconds, combining both player buffer and additional CDN delays. Rob noted that while player teams have the technical capability to implement such metrics, there’s resistance due to performance pressure to optimize reliability over low latency.
Latency Measurement Discussion
- Robin expressed concerns about measuring and discussing latency in their work, citing potential misunderstandings and additional workload. Michael suggested that TAG could potentially measure latency between different players as an interesting project.
- Robin clarified that the focus should be on understanding the full latency, including contributions from both the player and the CDN, emphasizing the importance of context in these measurements.
Video Streaming Latency Measurement Discussion
- Michael and Robin discussed measuring latency in video streaming, focusing on comparing measurements from different points in the streaming process, including the origin server and player display.
- Michael explained his method of using fingerprinting technology through HDMI connections to measure latency, which would allow for comparison with CDN and other upstream/downstream points.
- They agreed to further discuss this at the NAB event, where Michael could demonstrate the technology in more detail.
- The conversation concluded with a brief acknowledgment of the progress on latency measurement work items over the past few months.
Latency Measurement Approaches Discussion
- The team discussed latency measurement approaches, with Rob explaining two methods: a detailed breakdown of individual components and a more holistic workflow approach that considers additional delays like sensor buttons and Scuddy tones.
- Robin shared insights from industry examples, noting that real-world latency can vary significantly from theoretical measurements due to factors like ad tech, remote ingest, and profanity delays.
- The group briefly discussed CMCD (Conviva Metrics and Content Delivery) as a new standard for player-level data collection, though Michael raised questions about aggregating this data to a stream or channel level for monitoring purposes.
Next Meeting: Thursday, April 16, 2026 9am PDT
Chat Record:
Rob shares: https://www.ezdrm.com/c2pa-video-signature-service-ezdrm