Robin led a discussion on latency measurement and reporting in video players, proposing that players should be able to report their own latency metrics including buffer size, presentation timestamps, and real-time information. Dzmitriy confirmed that players already report buffer information through CMCD (Content Management and Control Dashboard) specifications, though further verification of the current capabilities was needed. The conversation then shifted to C2PA (Content Authenticity Protocol), which Robin explained is an emerging standard for authenticating video content through cryptographic signatures, though Dzmitriy noted that standard metadata fields in AVC already exist for capturing frame capture times. Finally, they discussed ATSC 3.0 broadcasting standards, where Dzmitriy explained that the main latency contributor in current implementations is the DASH packaging level rather than encoding, typically resulting in around 2 seconds of minimum latency due to 2-second chunk sizes.
1. Dzmitriy – Check the CMCD spec (and CMCDv2) to confirm what player buffer/latency information is reported and if relevant metrics are already specified.
2. Dzmitriy – Contact Ricardo Resende via Slack to discuss his latency measurement experiments and preliminary results for ATSC 3.0/TV 3.0 in Brazil.
- Robin – Contact Nicholas Levy (Qualabs) to ask about details of player reporting in CMCD/CMCDv2 and player latency metrics.
- Robin – Reach out to Ricardo Resende (Globo) to discuss ATSC 3.0/TV 3.0 latency measurements and experiences, particularly regarding chunk size and end-to-end latency in the Brazilian deployment.
- Robin – Monitor for and respond to the expected liaison request from ATSC regarding assistance with ATSC 3.0 latency, and coordinate with relevant group members as needed.
- Antitrust Statement & Player Latency Accountability Metrics
- Robin led a discussion about player latency accountability in consumer products, noting that player code issues often go unaddressed due to perceived lack of business impact.
- He proposed adding self-reporting metrics to players, including information about segmented playback, real-time and presentation timestamps, and buffer status.
- The meeting began with waiting for Michael, who couldn’t attend due to a customer call, and included Dzmitriy who joined from Bulgaria.
Media Player Latency Reporting Discussion
- Robin and Dzmitriy discussed the ability of media players to report their latency and buffer information.
- They explored how players could determine and report their position in the buffer, including the use of presentation timestamps (PTS) and decoding time stamps (DTS).
- Dzmitriy suggested checking the CMCD specification to see if players already report this information to CDNs.
- They also mentioned a recent update to CMCDv2 and discussed potentially consulting with Nicholas Levy from Qualabs for more information.
Video Latency and Authentication Standards
- Robin and Dzmitriy discussed three main topics related to video latency and authentication standards.
- They explored C2PA (Content Authenticity Protocol), which aims to cryptographically verify the authenticity of video content, though Dzmitriy noted that standard AVC already has built-in metadata for capturing frame times.
- They also discussed ATSC 3.0, where Mexican broadcasters are seeking help to ensure over-the-air latency meets or exceeds current ATSC 1.0 standards, with Dzmitriy explaining that the main latency contributor in DASH packaging is typically around 100-200 milliseconds.
- The conversation concluded with plans to reach out to Ricardo Resende from Brazil, who has already conducted latency measurements for ATSC 3.0 implementation, as an official liaison request from ATSC is expected to come through soon.
Next Meeting: Thursday, May 28, 2026 9 am PDT