SVTA_LOGO_FINAL_revised_2022

Security Meeting Minutes
July 21st, 2026 8:00am to 9:00am PT</p

Attendees

Kei Foo (Charter Communications)
Srikanth Varadarajan (Netflix)
Brian Paxton (Kingsmead Security)
James Robinson (Comcast/NBCUniversal)
Kieron Edwards (Comcast/NBCUniversal)
Ed Guy ()
Filip Paun (Netflix)
Jean-louis Diascorn (Harmonic)
Krzysztof Kwiatek (Irdeto)
Laurent Piron (Nagra Kudelski)
Moshi Elad (Synamedia)
Peter Kocic (Warner Bros Discovery)
Richelle Morgan (Irdeto)
Tom Southall (Warner Bros Discovery)
Andrew Gerrie (Comcast/NBCUniversal)
Yasser Syed (Streaming Video Technology Alliance (SME))
Nicolas Weil (Amazon)
Pavlo Kalmykov (Paramount)

Minutes

  • Summary

The SVTA Security Working Group held its first breakout session on post-quantum cryptography (PQC) and device security. The session was led by Srikanth from Netflix’s ecosystem security team and brought together security professionals from major streaming providers, device manufacturers, DRM vendors, and chipset partners. The call focused on understanding PQC threats specific to the streaming device ecosystem and establishing a coordinated industry response.

 

 

  • Action Items
  • Launch dedicated PQC work stream within SVTA Security Working Group, with Srikanth volunteering to lead
  • Create PQC-specific threat model document as the first project deliverable (separate from the existing OTT streaming threat model).
  • Srikanth to complete project definition documentation to formalize the work stream within SVTA.
  • Engage with SOC vendors and device manufacturers to align on PQC readiness requirements

 

 

  • Antitrust Statement and WG Discussion

Introduction to Call

  • The call began with an introduction to Kei Foo, Charter (Security WG Co-Chair) and Srikanth Varadarajan, Netflix, who will be leading the call.
  • The group did a round of introductions.

Discussion Highlights

  • Kieron Edwards acknowledged that obtaining a device’s public key is a prerequisite for quantum-based key factoring attacks, adding a practical barrier.
  • He noted that software-level PQC changes (e.g., TLS using ML-KEM) are relatively straightforward to implement despite handshake and memory overhead.
  • He expressed concern that cryptographically relevant quantum computers remain a very large engineering leap — potentially analogous to fusion energy (“always 10 years away”).
  • Pointed out scalability barriers to deploying a forged-signed image at scale: domain ownership, internet trust infrastructure, and head-end monitoring would all need to be defeated simultaneously.
  • Kieron confirmed Comcast’s current approach: blow fuses for both RSA and MLDSA to satisfy both US (clean break) and European (hybrid) regulatory preferences.
  • He raised concern that MLDSA, being new, could itself have a fatal flaw discovered post-deployment, potentially leaving “PQC-safe” devices vulnerable with no update path for immutable bootloader logic.
  • Filip Paun framed the choice as: actively contribute knowledge and context to help device partners do this correctly, or take a back seat and let it pass.
  • He endorsed Srikanth’s call to action as the right posture for the industry group.
  • Nicolas Weil confirmed he manages the security roadmap with SOC vendors and OEMs at Prime Video but had not yet engaged deeply on PQC beyond AES-256.
  • He asked about realistic timelines for the work stream; received confirmation that 2030 is the convergence point requiring silicon decisions now.
  • He expressed willingness to actively contribute to the work stream.
  • Yasser Syed asked whether reactive mitigation (e.g., revoking a detected cloned device) could offset the impact of a root of trust breach.
  • Kieron confirmed: unique immutable hardware identifiers per device enable detection of cloning (e.g., two devices with same ID connecting simultaneously triggers alerts), mirroring smart card cloning countermeasures used by Sky.
  • Srikanth added: hardware root of trust enables device recovery; the device ID backed by that root of trust enables service-level recovery.
  • James Robinson noted that broadcast switch-off timelines (e.g., UK government targeting ~2034 for broadcast support end) will drive mass deployment of low-cost IP-only devices that will remain in the field for decades.
  • He framed this as an additional socioeconomic pressure on the PQC migration timeline.

Key Takeaways

  • The session established consensus that secure boot and hardware root of trust represent the highest-priority targets for PQC migration in the streaming device ecosystem.
  • Key factors driving this urgency include:
    • Long device lifespans (7–10+ years for TVs and set-top boxes) that extend well into the quantum risk horizon
    • Irreversibility of hardware decisions once silicon is manufactured
    • The 2030–2035 industry migration timeline requiring silicon decisions today
  • The group endorsed a stacked/hybrid signing approach combining classical (RSA/ECC) and post-quantum (MLDSA) algorithms as the near-term standard, providing defense-in-depth during the transition period.
  • Participants discussed practical threat scenarios, mitigation strategies, and the balance between preparing for quantum threats while maintaining realistic risk assessments.
  • The consensus was to take proactive action now to influence device partner decisions rather than wait for quantum computers to mature.
  • Calls will continue bi-weekly.

 

 

Next Meeting:  Tuesday, August 4, 2026 8am PDT

Have A Question ABout Membership?

Schedule A Meeting

[hfcm id="18"]

Send An Email

Don’t want to schedule a face-to-face meeting just now? No problem. Simply send your membership question to info@streamingvideoalliance.org or fill out the form below and someone will get back to you as soon as possible.