SVTA_LOGO_FINAL_revised_2022

Measurement/QoE Meeting Minutes
March 11th, 2026 8:00am to 9:00am PT</p

Attendees

Tony Stott (Streaming Video Technology Alliance (SME))
Sean McCarthy (Streaming Video Technology Alliance (SME))
Will Law (Akamai)
Casey Occhialini (Paramount)
Joan Treveset (Castlabs)
Kyle Faber (Hydrolix)
Rob Walch (Apple)
Slavik Lozben ()
Yasser Syed (Streaming Video Technology Alliance (SME))
Bill Redmann (Interdigital)
Jun Heider (Streaming Video Technology Alliance (SME))

Minutes

  • Summary

The QoE WG Call focused on refining error codes for video streaming, addressing feedback from Rob from Apple and Casey. Key updates included adding a “switch to higher latency” error, renaming “alternate rendition load error” to “secondary asset list load error,” and differentiating between primary and secondary manifest load errors. The group also discussed the CDN project, proposing an open-source JavaScript tool to measure CDN performance using test object downloads. Will Law emphasized the importance of using CMCD v2 for more accurate data collection, while Sean highlighted the need for standardized metrics and potential energy metrics in future versions.

 

 

  • Action Items
  • Follow up with the group after reviewing notes to clarify the intended behavior and scope of the “alternate rendition load error” and report back so its usage can be confirmed or corrected.
  • Share the updated CDN performance benchmarking project proposal deck, including additional slides and alternative approaches (including CMCD-based methods), with the group before the next meeting so they can review it ahead of time.
  • Update the QoE error-codes specification document to reflect today’s decisions (rename error codes such as switch-to-higher-latency and primary/secondary manifest/asset-list errors, remove the alternate rendition load error entry, and renumber the manifest-related entries), then post the revised version on Slack within the next few days for group review.

 

 

  • Antitrust Statement and WG Discussion

Error Codes Discussion and Initial Feedback

  • Tony Stott initiates the meeting, suggesting a quick discussion on error codes before moving to MQA.
  • Will Law suggests focusing on Sean’s proposal for the next project instead of MQA.
  • Tony Stott begins reviewing feedback from Rob from Apple, mentioning updates to error codes and adding a section on stacking error codes.
  • Bill Redmann suggests changing “switch to standard latency” to “switch to higher latency” to account for multiple latencies.
  • Tony Stott agrees and updates the error codes accordingly.

Content Steering and CDN Switch Errors

  • Tony Stott discusses errors related to content steering, including content steering manifest load error and unable to pass content steering manifest.
  • Sean inquires about specific errors that might arise from triggering a CDN switch, such as DNS resolution errors.
  • Tony Stott acknowledges the need for errors related to CDN switches but notes that current errors do not explicitly cover this.
  • Bill Redmann and Sean discuss whether the act of switching CDNs is an error or an event, ultimately deciding to leave it out of the error codes.

Alternate Rendition Load Error and Interstitial Asset Load Error

  • Tony Stott explains the alternate rendition load error, which was intended to cover errors related to alternate content like picture-in-picture.
  • Rob Walch (Apple) and Casey Occhialini discuss the need for clarity on this error and its relevance to HLS and DASH.
  • Tony Stott updates the error codes to reflect the discussion, including renaming some errors for clarity.
  • Casey Occhialini suggests moving the interstitial asset load error to the playback section for better alignment.

Asset List Load Error and Secondary Manifest Load Error

  • Casey Occhialini and Bill Redmann discuss the need for a more generic name for the asset list load error, considering both HLS and DASH use cases.
  • Joan Treveset (castlabs) suggests using “secondary asset list load error” for HLS-specific cases.
  • Tony Stott updates the error codes to include primary and secondary manifest load errors, differentiating between primary and secondary content.
  • The group agrees to rename and reorganize the error codes for better clarity and alignment with industry standards.

Next Project: CDN Performance Benchmarking

  • Sean introduces the next project on CDN performance benchmarking, summarizing the problem statement and proposed solution.
  • Bill Redmann emphasizes the importance of measuring consumer quality of experience and suggests considering sustainability metrics.
  • Sean explains the proposed open-source JavaScript code that would perform test object downloads and generate performance beacons.
  • The group discusses the relevance of the project in light of CMCD v2 and the need for standardized metrics.

Concerns and Alternative Approaches

  • Will Law expresses concerns about the proposed approach of running a pseudo player in the background, suggesting CMCD v2 as a more reliable method.
  • Sean acknowledges the challenges and agrees to explore alternative approaches using CMCD data.
  • The group discusses the need for a common vernacular to measure CDN performance and the potential impact on business and technical decisions.
  • Sean plans to share additional slides and approaches in the next meeting, aiming to address the concerns and refine the project scope.

 

 

 

Next Meeting:  Wednesday, March 25, 2026 8am PDT

Have A Question ABout Membership?

Schedule A Meeting

[hfcm id="18"]

Send An Email

Don’t want to schedule a face-to-face meeting just now? No problem. Simply send your membership question to info@streamingvideoalliance.org or fill out the form below and someone will get back to you as soon as possible.