SVTA_LOGO_FINAL_revised_2022

Measurement/QoE Meeting Minutes
April 8th, 2026 8:00am to 9:00am PT</p

Attendees

Sean McCarthy (Streaming Video Technology Alliance (SME))
Adrian Roe (Id3as)
Brenton Ough (Touchstream)
Rob Walch (Apple)
Yuriy Reznik (Disney Streaming Service)
Alan Stein (V-Nova)
Walter Bardelle (MainStreaming)

Minutes

  • Summary

The QoE working group meeting focused on planning a new industry survey to identify the most pressing media quality and observability problems in streaming. The group discussed creating a comprehensive list of questions covering both quality-related issues and data management challenges, with participants agreeing to develop questions offline before the next meeting. They also reviewed progress on composite metrics development, particularly around CMCD and CMSD data, with discussion of how to better capture and beacon quality metrics like MQA scores. The team agreed to schedule a follow-up meeting the following week to continue survey planning and review documentation, with a particular focus on preparing for the upcoming NAB conference where several members will be presenting related work.

 

 

  • Action Items
  • Sean: Create and share a draft document of survey questions for the new QoE/observability survey, and add it to the SVTA drive for group contribution.
    • Found here – https://docs.google.com/document/d/13QnUOGLBDfM2XR4m4yRgX9wFP-9J9HxjxbLO-bU2zlc/edit?usp=sharing
  • All participants: Review and contribute potential survey questions to the shared document before the next meeting, aiming to prepare at least some questions for discussion.
  • Sean: Work with Hali to add next week’s meeting to the SVTA calendar for 8:30am PT/11:30am ET (half-hour session) to continue survey work.
  • Share both the QoE survey draft and the CMCD composite metric document in the SVTA Slack channel.

 

 

  • Antitrust Statement and WG Discussion

Intro to Call

  • Sean was unable to chair the call until the 30-minute mark, so the group had casual conversations while waiting for him to join.
  • Some topics discussed were the upcoming NAB show, the Content Steering document in the Players and Playback WG, and other technical topics.
  • If you want to see the notes from this discussion, reach out to Hali.

Operations Survey and Quality Metrics

  • Brenton proposed redoing an operations survey similar to a previous Touchstream and SVTA survey that received good response rates.
  • The discussion focused on quality metrics, with Adrian noting that the MQA system effectively uses two numbers for audio and video quality scores, though it could potentially be extended to include metadata quality.
  • Yuriy raised a concern about potential misuse of AI-generated annotations being called quality metrics, while Adrian discussed the balance between simple metrics and detailed data in SEI messages, noting that too much detailed information could make messages larger than the video itself.

Lip Sync Metrics and Survey

  • The group discussed lip sync issues in media streaming, with Adrian explaining that while lip sync problems typically occur upstream, they can be challenging to detect and measure accurately.
  • The team explored potential metrics for quantifying lip sync delays, including average delta and variance measurements.
  • Brenton suggested adding lip sync to their upcoming survey to better understand the current prevalence of the issue, particularly distinguishing between VOD and live streaming contexts.
  • The discussion concluded with agreement that a survey would be a useful approach to gather real-world information about media streaming problems.

CMCD Metric Definition Project Discussion

  • The team discussed two main projects: a pivot to a CMCD composite metric definition project with a smaller scope, and an exploration into bigger industry QoE-related problems.
  • For the second project, they considered creating a new survey, with Brenton noting that the previous survey process involved using MailChimp and combining multiple lists, though the hardest part was developing good questions.
  • Sean suggested they could leverage AI tools for writing summaries, similar to how JT handled it previously.

User Experience Survey and Metrics Discussion

  • The team discussed two main topics: a User Experience survey and a composite metric for streaming quality.
  • For the survey, they agreed to focus on identifying the most pressing problems in media quality and observability in the industry.
  • Question brainstorming document –
    • https://docs.google.com/document/d/13QnUOGLBDfM2XR4m4yRgX9wFP-9J9HxjxbLO-bU2zlc/edit?usp=sharing
  • The group decided to prepare questions offline before their next meeting and scheduled a follow-up meeting for the following Wednesday (April 15) at 8:30am PT/11:30am ET.
  • Regarding the composite metric, they reviewed an existing document and discussed the potential benefits of creating standardized metrics based on CMCD and CMSD data to help operations teams and business stakeholders better understand streaming data at scale.

 

 

Next Meeting:  Wednesday, April 15, 2026 8am PDT

 

Have A Question ABout Membership?

Schedule A Meeting

[hfcm id="18"]

Send An Email

Don’t want to schedule a face-to-face meeting just now? No problem. Simply send your membership question to info@streamingvideoalliance.org or fill out the form below and someone will get back to you as soon as possible.