SVTA_LOGO_FINAL_revised_2022

Measurement/QoE Meeting Minutes
July 1st, 2026 8:00am to 9:00am PT</p

Attendees

Tony Stott (Streaming Video Technology Alliance (SME))
Glenn Deen (Comcast/NBCUniversal)
Brenton Ough (Touchstream)
Bill Redmann (Interdigital)
Slavik Lozben ()
Yasser Syed (Streaming Video Technology Alliance (SME))

Minutes

  • Summary

The meeting focused on discussing metric definitions and content workflow updates for the QoE workstream. Hali reported that MQA content was fully published and available on the website, while player error codes were waiting for board approval before publication. The team extensively discussed metric scope definitions, with Tony presenting a framework that includes visit, playback, and asset levels to avoid metric bloat, while incorporating different aggregations like average, 95th, and 99th percentiles based on stakeholder needs. The group debated terminology alignment with CMCD specifications, particularly around session IDs (SID) and content IDs (CID), and discussed the complexity of measuring quality for multi-asset playbacks and user-initiated events like seeking and rewinding. Bill raised important considerations about distinguishing between different types of buffering events and the need to separate user-initiated rebuffering from system-induced failures. The team also touched on audio dropout metrics and the technical challenges of implementing audio buffer management in players.

 

 

  • Action Items
  • Tony to simplify and clarify the state diagram for metric implementation, particularly the “start timer” and “stop timer” nomenclature.
  • Tony to check and clarify the mapping between the proposed “playback” concept and the CMCD “session ID” (SID) and “content ID” (CID) definitions.
  • All participants to provide feedback, comments, and ideas on the metric definitions document.

 

 

  • Antitrust Statement and WG Discussion

Document Updates and Metrics Framework

  • The team discussed updates on documents in ratification, with Hali confirming that MQA was published and available for download, while player error codes is awaiting board approval.
  • Tony presented a revised metric definition framework focusing on scope levels including visit, playback, and asset, with emphasis on using aggregation methods (average, 95th percentile, 99th percentile) as parameters rather than creating separate metrics.
  • The discussion included mapping these definitions to CMCD terminology, particularly around session IDs (SID) and content IDs (CID), with participants agreeing that a playback could contain multiple SIDs and CIDs to accommodate various content types and user experiences.

VOD Playlist Implementation Discussion

  • The team discussed implementing playlist functionality for VOD sessions, focusing on how to handle buffering and metrics.
  • Tony emphasized the importance of maintaining metric integrity when users transition between playlist items, noting that players should pre-buffer before starting the next item to avoid artificial improvements in average start times.
  • Bill raised additional complexity around handling buffering events during trick play within the same asset.

Rebuffering Event Classification Challenges

  • The team discussed challenges in distinguishing between different types of rebuffering events, particularly when users rewind through ad breaks or seek to specific positions.
  • Bill and Yasser highlighted the complexity of buffer management, noting that player-dependent factors like buffer size and live edge segment requests affect rebuffering performance.
  • The group agreed that system-induced rebuffering should be treated as a separate metric from user-initiated actions, with Tony suggesting that connection-induced rebuffering metrics exclude seek and pause events from the numerator.

Media Playback Delay Metrics Discussion

  • The team discussed metrics for measuring start delay in media playback, focusing on customer experience and technical implementation.
  • Bill emphasized the importance of distinguishing between server and player capabilities in solving playback issues, while Tony presented a state diagram to visualize the metric implementation process.
  • The group agreed to simplify the diagram’s terminology and clarify the distinction between different failure conditions to avoid polluting the metrics.
  • Bill also raised a question about separate reporting for video and audio playback delays, particularly regarding audio starting after video.

Audio and Video Quality Metrics

  • The team discussed quality of experience metrics for video and audio content, focusing on how to measure and handle audio dropouts versus video dropouts.
  • Bill and Tony explored the technical challenges of implementing audio lag metrics and buffer management, while Brenton highlighted that audio dropouts are more common than video dropouts.
  • The group discussed player-based solutions including packet loss concealment and frequency domain processing, with Tony requesting team members to provide feedback in the shared document before their next meeting in two weeks.

 

 

 

Next Meeting:  Wednesday, July 15, 2026 8am PDT

 

Have A Question ABout Membership?

Schedule A Meeting

[hfcm id="18"]

Send An Email

Don’t want to schedule a face-to-face meeting just now? No problem. Simply send your membership question to info@streamingvideoalliance.org or fill out the form below and someone will get back to you as soon as possible.