SVTA_LOGO_FINAL_revised_2022

Security Meeting Minutes
October 20th, 2026 8:00am to 9:00am PT</p

Attendees

Kei Foo (Charter Communications)
Chinara Satkeeva (Google)
Srikanth Varadarajan (Netflix)
Mark Nakano (Warner Bros Discovery)
Hugo Gonzalez (Warner Bros Discovery)
Robin Wilson (Streaming Video Technology Alliance (SME))
Tejal Gupte (Google)
Yasser Syed (Streaming Video Technology Alliance (SME))
Roger Bourget (Comcast/NBCUniversal)
Walter Bardelle (MainStreaming)
James Robinson (Comcast/NBCUniversal)
Sam Perriton-branch ()
Eamonn Cunnane (Comcast/NBCUniversal)
Andrew Gerrie (Comcast/NBCUniversal)
Lisa Robinson (Comcast/NBCUniversal)
Prashant Grover (Google)
Alex Lee (Google)
Moshi Elad (Synamedia)

Minutes

  • Summary

The meeting focused on the progress of the D2P document and the key rotation project. Mark reported that Brian had been restructuring the D2P document and that he had not added new content. Mark and Srikanth discussed the overlap between D2P log analysis and Niranjan’s work on anomalous device types, noting that DRM logs are used in both. Kei and Chinara discussed the key rotation project, clarifying that DASH-IF is responsible for the spec while the Security Working Group focuses on best practice guidelines. Moshi noted that Apple recently released early announcement and advisory key features, which may impact the solution. The group discussed the thundering herd problem and the need for a clear division of responsibility between the Security Working Group and DASH-IF. Kei also provided an update on the CDN streaming log analysis paper, proposing a revised abstract and title to clarify its purpose as a vendor-agnostic reference of required data fields.

 

 

  • Action Items
  • Chinara to follow up with Hali to get the presentation that Laurent presented at the Q4 meeting and send it to the group.
  • Srikanth to sync with Niranjan later this week to discuss combining the D2P log analysis project with the anomalous device project and provide an update via email.
  • Kei to ensure Laurent and DASH-IF are invited to the next call on November 3rd to discuss key rotation.
  • Kei to sync with Laurent separately to clarify the split of responsibility between the Security Working Group and DASH-IF regarding key rotation.
  • Kei to follow up with Glenn and JT on the CDN streaming log analysis paper and, if they agree, rework the abstract and retitle the paper before the end of the year.

 

  • Antitrust Statement and WG Discussion

SVTA Antitrust Policy Review

  • The meeting began with Kei noting that there was no DASH-IF call scheduled that morning, and Brian was absent due to a last-minute emergency.
  • Chinara started the formal meeting by reviewing the antitrust policy and directing participants to review the complete policy document before contributing to discussions.

D2P Project Updates

  • Mark discussed updates to a document that Brian was working on restructuring, but noted he hadn’t added much content himself.
  • He mentioned that Naranjan wants to include some device or anomalous device type analysis, particularly related to DRM logs that they analyze.
  • Srikanth commented that the CDN log analysis and DRM analysis are closely tied to suspicious device activity, and mentioned plans to sync with Naranjan later to explore potentially combining these projects.

Project Integration and Key Management

  • The team discussed combining multiple projects into one and addressed Naranjan’s work on a database of bad devices, with Mark suggesting they could either create a separate section or integrate Naranjan’s deeper analysis into their existing work.
  • Chinara clarified that Mark’s D2P document focuses on analyzing CDN and DRM logs for CDN leaching, with potential cross-referencing between access and DRM license requests.
  • Kei mentioned Brian’s interest in resurfacing a key rotation project involving high-frequency key cycling, which would address different rotation frequencies for HD versus SD resolution and aim to curb thundering herd problems through trusted client key distribution.

DASH Content Security Key Rotation

  • The group discussed key rotation for DASH content security, with Kei explaining that DASH-IF would focus on updating the specification while implementing a short-term solution involving high-frequency key cycling for trusted clients.
  • Yasser inquired about the specific frequency, to which Kei responded that studios had requested keys every 10 minutes based on previous discussions.
  • The conversation revealed uncertainty about next steps and leadership responsibility, as Moshi noted that the content protection call was canceled because key rotation was expected to be discussed in this security group.

Key Rotation Planning Meeting

  • The team discussed key rotation and agreed to prioritize it over other topics in their upcoming November 3 meeting.
  • Chinara will follow up with Hali to obtain the Q4 meeting presentation from Laurent and share it with the group.
  • The team debated whether to split the session between key rotation and D2P log analysis, with Srikanth suggesting they prioritize key rotation due to its immediate action requirements, and Kei considering whether to include the Content Protection Group meeting before their discussion.

Key Rotation Implementation Planning

  • The team discussed creating a practice document for key rotation implementation in streaming services, with Kei explaining that it would complement DASH-IF security work by providing specific implementation details and best practices.
  • Moshi noted that key rotation specifications have been stuck for over two years and require breakthrough progress.
  • The group reviewed an existing draft document on DRM high FQ rotation, though work was paused pending completion of the specs.
  • Yasser asked about handling key rotation for VOD stitched channels, with Moshi indicating that implementation would follow the relevant specifications, though current key rotation signaling is tied to DASH period and may face thundering herd problems.

Key Rotation Specification Challenges

  • The team discussed key rotation challenges, particularly focusing on “thundering herd” peak loads that occur when multiple devices simultaneously request licenses for the same content.
  • Kei clarified that the current focus is on live linear services rather than VOD, as VOD typically uses track keys with dedicated keys for each resolution and audio stream.
  • The group agreed that progress on key rotation solutions cannot move forward until the specification is finalized, and Kei committed to syncing with Laurent and others to clarify the process and ensure alignment with DASH-IF’s specification authority.

DASH-IF Role and Paper Revisions

  • The group discussed DASH-IF’s role in influencing MPEG dash constructs, with Kei explaining they deferred to DASH-IF’s greater influence and didn’t want to assume responsibility for work DASH was already doing.

CDN Log Analysis Paper Abstract

  • Kei proposed rewriting the abstract and retitling the CDN streaming log analysis paper to clarify its vendor-agnostic purpose of listing recommended data fields for log analysis.
  • The team agreed to await feedback from Glenn and JT on this proposal before proceeding with revisions to be completed by year-end.

 

 

Next Meeting:  Tuesday, November 3, 2026 8am PST

 

Have A Question ABout Membership?

Schedule A Meeting

[hfcm id="18"]

Send An Email

Don’t want to schedule a face-to-face meeting just now? No problem. Simply send your membership question to info@streamingvideoalliance.org or fill out the form below and someone will get back to you as soon as possible.