The meeting focused on progress updates and planning for various Ultra HD Forum initiatives, including content acquisition, guidelines development, and service descriptions. The group discussed challenges with obtaining content from DFB, with James reporting frustration over slow internal progress despite forwarding the request on June 10th. Bill provided feedback on a content acquisition paragraph, suggesting it needed a clearer introduction and more polite language, while the team explored the concept of adapting content for different use cases including advertising integration and service mocking. The discussion included updates on blog content development, with James noting convergence in changes to a blog post, and plans to incorporate NASA-related content into both the Indigo book and Violet book guidelines. The team reviewed survey planning for understanding the health of Ultra HD services, with Bill sharing a 2017 survey as a reference point and Ranjeet suggesting keeping surveys under 20 questions for better response rates. The conversation ended with brainstorming on service use cases, where Yasser presented a framework distinguishing between consumer utility services and creation/preservation utility services, with the group discussing how this decomposition could inform technical working group requirements.
Bill
- Send the 2017 IBC Service Provider Workshop survey document to SVTA.
James
- Chase internally for a response regarding the paragraph sent to the DFB guys, as no response has been received.
Lindsey
- Correct the minutes from June 3rd by removing the mixed-up content from the last bullet of Section 3.
Yasser
- Work on revising the introductory paragraph for requesting demo content, possibly creating one or two versions.
- Review the changes made by James to the blog post and make further changes if necessary.
- Discuss with JT about the survey.
- Continue brainstorming and developing the list of service types in the service document.
- Contact Ben to inquire about any previous Ultra HD Forum surveys for reference.
- Follow up with Rebecca and the NASA image people to incorporate their information into the guidelines (Violet or Indigo book).
- Continue updating the guidelines, with a process to mark sections as updated.
- Antitrust Statement & MPEG IIF Project Status Update
- The group discussed the status of MPEG IIF, which is expected to begin on Friday with no anticipated issues, though James noted they are waiting for an official announcement and details about the ballot process.
- James mentioned starting a project with Bill to establish a 337 data type for MPEG-A, CIAF needed for SDI workflows.
- The discussion touched on the importance of signaling in automation and third-party material handling, particularly regarding HDR and 2110 implementations.
Meeting Minutes and Follow-up Issues
- The team discussed issues with the June 3 meeting minutes that contained information from two separate calls and agreed to fix the errors.
- Bill reported no progress on FIFA-related work, while James expressed frustration about delays in responding to the DFB paragraph that was sent on June 10, which he had forwarded to the appropriate internal contacts.
- James indicated he would need to follow up again on the DFB matter due to the lack of response.
Content Request Strategy Discussion
- Yasser discussed seeking content for internal collaboration and demonstrations across various working groups.
- Bill suggested adding a polite introduction to the request and clarifying the distinction between test and demo content.
- Lindsey was unsure about historical practices of content requests, and Ranjeet shared that DTG uses their own test material content with IPR for demonstrations in collaborative projects.
Content Adaptability Strategy Discussion
- The team discussed content adaptability, with Yasser explaining that highly adaptable content could include AI applications, advertising overlays, and non-linear placements in sports content.
- Bill suggested refining the concept to distinguish between "enticing" content for public display and "challenging" content for testing purposes, particularly regarding SDR and HDR formats.
- The discussion concluded with plans to develop tailored paragraphs for requesting content from potential partners, with Yasser agreeing to work on one or two versions of the request.
Document and Content Revisions Discussion
- James and Yasser discussed the status of document changes, with James having made additional changes on top of Yasser’s revisions.
- Yasser agreed to review James's changes and potentially make further adjustments.
- Bill suggested converting substantive revisions of guidelines into blog format, and Yasser mentioned incorporating NASA content into both the Indigo book as a monograph and the Violet book as a diagram of current events.
- The discussion included details about NASA's presentation on using both RF and optical receivers for data transmission from spacecraft.
Space Mission Survey Planning
- The group discussed plans for satellite constellations around the moon and communication coverage for space missions.
- They reviewed action items including corrections to meeting minutes and progress on service descriptions, website review, and brainstorming lists.
- The main focus was on planning a survey targeting broadcasters, service providers, and VOD vendors to assess the health of Ultra High Def services, with Bill suggesting they should check if the Ultra HD Forum conducted a similar survey in the past 5+ years to establish trend data.
UHDF Survey Development Discussion
- The team discussed developing a survey about UHDF (Ultra High Definition) services, with Yasser presenting a diagram to explore questions about UHDF value in live events versus canned content.
- Bill shared a previous 2017 survey as a reference and suggested keeping future surveys under 20 questions to ensure better response rates.
- The group also discussed decomposing UHDF service use cases into two categories: consumer-level utilities involving financial exchanges, and creation/preservation utilities focusing on value retention through features like exclusivity and discoverability.
- Bill noted this approach represents a sophisticated service decomposition similar to microservices architecture, which could have interesting technological implications for implementation.
Next Meeting: Wednesday, July 1, 2026 7am PDT
Chat Record:
Regarding - corrections to the JUN 3 UHDF WG minutes:
Section 2: last sentence seems to be bleed from the QoE WG.
Looks like last three bullets of section 3 are bleed from QOE WG.
In section 4, the last segment “Stream Health Metrics Definition Discussion” and its three bullets eems to be from QoE.
https://tally.so/r/ZjvLye?source=SVTA
Survey Discussions: (French Olympics diagram, Single Master Dual Focus)
Targets: Broadcasters, Service Providers, Channel Providers, VOD
- Single channel support versus opportunity for multiple channel support
- Burdens of having a 24hr UHD channel
- Do people notice?
- Scaling of Indoor versus Outdoor scenary
- Upscaling downstream in TV Sets ( Resolution, Dynamic Range)
- Bandwidth Constraints
Single master Dual Focus