The UHDF WG met to discuss updates to their UHDF survey and service documentation. Yasser led the discussion on survey revisions, proposing to add new questions about distributor feeds, UHDF material creation at devices, advertising in UHDF, and signaling methods for UHDF content. The team reviewed existing survey categories and discussed pruning down the 22-question format while adding relevant topics like high frame rates, next generation audio, and dynamic metadata. Bill suggested organizing questions into branching categories based on respondent type and interests to improve survey engagement. The group also reviewed service documentation categories including video services, network traffic management, cross-entity B2B workflow automation, and accessibility features, with James providing insights about European Accessibility Act compliance and associated fines for non-compliance.
James
- Continue following up with the DFP/DFB guys and report progress.
- Review and update the Next Generation Audio section of the survey.
Lindsey
- Look into how to find old surveys from other working groups and report back.
Yasser
- Work on revising the introductory paragraph for requesting demo content, possibly creating one or two versions. (not done)
- Get scene test material – grass is green
- Review the changes made by James to the blog post and make further changes if necessary.
- Discuss with JT about the survey. ( Add in “Production in Streaming:)
- Send the updated survey to James for review, specifically the Next Generation Audio section.
- Get Alan to look at the LCEVC broadcasts section of the survey.
- Obtain the SVTA Streaming Operations Survey in a non-fillable form and move it along for review.
- Contact Chris Lennon to discuss microservices.
- Start looking at and adjusting the blog post after the call.
- Continue brainstorming and developing the list of service types in the service document.
- Follow up with Rebecca and the NASA image people to incorporate their information into the guidelines (Violet or Indigo book). (get Slides from Rebecca)
- Continue updating the guidelines, with a process to mark sections as updated.
- Antitrust Statement & SVTA Surveys Discussion
- The meeting began with Yasser reviewing the SVTA antitrust statement and discussing the agenda, which focused on surveys and services discussions.
- Lindsey agreed to look into how to find older surveys from other working groups, while Yasser noted difficulty in locating them.
- The group briefly discussed a survey from the Streaming Operations WG, with Yasser expressing interest in reviewing its questions.
Project Updates and Content Planning
- James reported that DFB is quiet due to vacation and the World Cup, though Germany’s elimination might free up time.
- Lindsey confirmed receiving highlighted notes from June 3rd and uploaded them to ARO.
- Yasser discussed working on service type stocks and found surveys for the Ultra HD Forum, while still trying to contact NASA’s imagery group for moon project information to propose for a violent book event.
- The team also discussed updating guidelines and survey sections, particularly adding distributor feeds content.
UHDF Survey Question Refinement
- Yasser and Bill discussed the need to prune and refine questions for a survey about UHDF material, particularly focusing on technical aspects like 4K feeds, UHDF signaling, and advertising in UHDF.
- They identified that the current 22 categories of questions could be too extensive and suggested replacing some questions with more relevant ones given the industry’s increased maturity.
- The discussion also touched on signaling UHDF in workflows and the potential use of 1080p as a fallback for broadcasting while maintaining quality at a distance.
Broadcast Video Resolution Standards
- The discussion focused on video resolution standards in broadcasting, with participants noting that while 4K content exists, 1080p has become the standard for both acquisition and distribution.
- Bill expressed concerns about the visual quality of FIFA content appearing flat and untextured, while Yasser suggested that detailed elements like grass texture could enhance immersive experiences.
- Lynn confirmed that 1080p is the current sweet spot for both acquisition and distribution, and the conversation concluded with questions about content re-monetization and the impact of broadband penetration on HDR services.
UHDF Survey Question Updates
- Yasser discussed the need to update survey questions on UHDF signaling and Next Generation Audio, asking James to review the Next Generation Audio section.
- Bill suggested reorganizing survey questions into categorized sections like quality of experience, distribution, and specific areas of interest to allow deeper engagement from respondents.
- Yasser emphasized the importance of understanding why UHD adoption has been slower than HD, noting the need to structure survey questions to address this question and comparing the different adoption timelines of HD and UHD technologies.
HDR Content Production Challenges
- Bill and Yasser discussed challenges with shooting HDR content in stadium environments where LED screens are extremely bright, causing color issues with reds appearing orange or white due to intense screen brightness.
- They explored the evolution of UHD formats, noting that dynamic metadata (like Dolby Vision and HDR10+) represents additional optimizations rather than separate formats, and identified a need to adjust their survey to better distinguish between HLG and PQ formats.
- The discussion concluded with confirmation that a Dolby Vision profile exists for HLG compatibility, and they noted that questions about UHD service value and concerns remain relevant for their survey.
User-Generated Content and UHD Services
- Bill and Yasser discussed incorporating user-generated content into surveys and addressed concerns about launching UHD services, including content availability and device market penetration.
- They explored questions related to energy consumption and sustainability, particularly how different TV modes affect HDR display.
- The conversation concluded with a discussion about creating a comprehensive list of questions across SVTA working groups and potentially developing separate surveys for different audiences.
Survey Streamlining and Service Categories
- The team discussed streamlining a survey by reducing the number of questions and implementing branching logic based on respondent roles (distribution, production, etc.).
- They reviewed various survey sections including HDR formats, high frame rates, and Next Generation Audio, with Yasser suggesting reorganization of questions to better reflect how respondents would answer based on their specific roles.
- The discussion also covered service categories and their values, including topics like content archiving, accessibility compliance (driven by legal requirements like the European Accessibility Act), and interactive services like betting, with the team identifying financial benefits and audience expansion as key motivations for implementing these services.
Next Meeting: Wednesday, July 15, 2026 7am PDT
Survey Discussions: (French Olympics diagram, Single Master Dual Focus)
Targets: Broadcasters, Service Providers, Channel Providers, VOD
- Single channel support versus opportunity for multiple channel support
- Burdens of having a 24hr UHD channel
- Do people notice?
- Scaling of Indoor versus Outdoor scenary
- Upscaling downstream in TV Sets ( Resolution, Dynamic Range)
- Bandwidth Constraints
Single master Dual Focus